Android isn’t killing sideloading, but the compromise is perfect


Sideloading has been a key part of Android since the beginning, not only delivering a lot of flexibility to Android, but also a sense of openness and freedom. After Google announced it would make major changes to sideloading, the community (somewhat understandably) panicked, but as Google has now shown exactly how its new sideloading flow on Android will work, I’m not only happy to see that sideloading isn’t going away at all, but that Google’s compromise is as close to perfect as I think we can reasonably get.


This issue of 9to5Google Weekender is a part of 9to5Google’s rebooted newsletter that highlights the biggest Google stories with added commentary and other tidbits. Sign up here to get it delivered to your inbox early!


“Android Developer Verification” has been referred to by some as the death of Android’s open nature. Google announced the change last year as a restriction to app installation, including sideloading, which would require developers to register with Google in order to allow their apps to be installed on Android devices. Google originally pitched this as being like an ID check at the airport – confirming the “who” an app is coming from.

The focus here was always on combating scams, including “convincing” fake apps, as well as cutting down on malware and other malicious attacks that were prevalent, especially through sideloading from sources outside of the Google Play Store. Google has been targeting scams on Android more aggressively over the years, to some success, in part by blocking sideloaded apps used in scams.

Advertisement – scroll for more content

This week, Google finally showed the new “advanced flow” that is designed to allow users (and developers) to sideload apps that aren’t from a registered developer.

The 4-step process asks the user to confirm that “no one is instructing me,” then starts a 24-hour delay. The user is asked to reboot their device to start the timer and, 24 hours later, they can continue the sideloading process after again acknowledging the risks – the delay only kicks in once, if you choose to leave it on “indefinitely.” So, really, this is just a one-time hurdle. The biggest “headache” is that developer options need to be turned on, but you can later turn them back off.

Google will be rolling this out to all versions of Android starting in August 2026.

And, in my eyes, it’s a near-perfect compromise.

Google has repeatedly made it clear that a “crackdown” on sideloading isn’t about removing functionality or freedom, it’s always been about user protection and, above all else, shutting down scams that are prevalent on Android in some regions. By limiting sideloading as it plans, Google doesn’t stop developers or even users from doing what they actually want to do, but it’s a massive wall in front of scammers.

Scammers often rely on creating timed pressure, a sense of urgency. A 24-hour waiting period with a couple of extra warnings in place? That’s a hard obstacle to those types of scams. It’s also a huge hassle for users that are being walked through more common scams. A personal example – a family member called me a few weeks ago after buying a cheap fitness tracker, asking why their homescreen had changed. As it turns out, the product had required they sideload an unknown app which replaced their launcher. I talked them through uninstalling it, but a 24-hour delay and all of these additional warning screens? The installation never would have happened.

It’s a thoughtful way of balancing user protection along with functionality. Because, while the “average Joe” needs to wait for that 24-hour period to end, developers and enthusiasts who need/want to sideload an app right away can still use the usual ADB tools. That’s a hassle for “normal” users – and even more so for scammers – but the people who really can’t wait the 24-hour period (which, again, only needs to be once) still have options.

And let’s not forget that, in many cases, you won’t have to deal with this anyway. Google’s developer verification program just requires developers to register, at which point sideloading becomes a non-issue with no waiting periods or anything else “in the way.”

What do you think of Google’s changes to Android sideloading? I’m sure there are plenty who still take issue with this but, as mentioned, I’m not sure there’s a better compromise out there. It could be worse.


This Week’s Top Stories

The Galaxy Z TriFold is dead already

Samsung has confirmed that, after just a few months, it is discontinuing the Galaxy Z TriFold. The reason? Samsung didn’t say, but a report suggests it boils down to complex manufacturing and the increasing pressure of the RAM/storage shortage.

More Top Stories


From the rest of 9to5

9to5Mac: Google begins testing dedicated Gemini app for Mac

9to5Toys: Major Switch 2 update delivers new Handheld Mode Boost to enhance Switch 1 games

Electrek: The US’s only true street-legal electric micro-car just got big upgrades


Follow Ben: Twitter/XThreads, Bluesky, and Instagram

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.





Source link

Leave a comment

Stay up to date
Register now to get updates on promotions and coupons.

Shopping cart

×